As major nations push Hamas to accept Israeli truce proposal, Palestinians hold out fragile hope

As major nations push Hamas to accept Israeli truce proposal, Palestinians hold out fragile hope

Britain and the United States on Monday urged Hamas to swiftly accept an Israeli proposal for a truce in the war as well as the release of Israeli hostages held by the Palestinian militant group.

Hamas negotiators were expected to meet Qatari and Egyptian mediators in Cairo on Monday to deliver a response to the phased truce proposal, which Israel presented over the weekend.

"Hamas has before it a proposal that is extraordinarily, extraordinarily generous on the part of Israel," U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken said at a meeting of the World Economic Forum (WEF) in the Saudi capital Riyadh.

"The only thing standing between the people of Gaza and a ceasefire is Hamas. They have to decide and they have to decide quickly," he said. "I'm hopeful that they will make the right decision."

As talks stretched on, Palestinians in Gaza said they were hopeful for a resolution despite being disappointed by previous failures to reach a deal.

"Our faith in God is strong, but every time they say there's a truce or negotiations, they sadly fail," said Mohamed Al-Sharif, 55. "It either fails because of [Israeli Prime Minister] Netanyahu or it fails because of Hamas, but what is the fault of the people?"

A man in a navy sweatshirt stands in on a sidewalk next to a public street. Three men walking down the street are visible in the background.
Mohamed Al-Sharif, 55, said he and other Palestinians have gone through several cycles of disappointment of hoping for a truce deal between Israel and Hamas over the past months of war. (Mohamed El Saife/CBC)

Speaking to CBC News from Rafah, Yasser Helles said he wasn't holding his breath.

"I hope.... But expectation? No, I don't expect it to succeed to be honest," said Helles, 56. "We expected a lot that it would succeed the last times."

A source briefed on the talks said Israel's proposal entailed a deal for the release of fewer than 40 of the roughly 130 hostages believed to be still held in Gaza in exchange for freeing Palestinians jailed in Israel.

A second phase of a truce would consist of a "period of sustained calm" — Israel's compromise response to a Hamas demand for a permanent ceasefire.

A total of 253 hostages were seized in a Hamas-led attack on southern Israel on Oct. 7 in which about 1,200 Israelis were also killed, according to Israeli counts. Israel retaliated by imposing a total siege on Gaza and mounting an air and ground assault that has killed about 34,500 Palestinians, according to Gaza health authorities.

The first pause in fighting in November saw the release of around half of the hostages held by Hamas. In that deal, Israel freed three times the number of Palestinians from its security prisons and admitted more humanitarian aid to Gaza.

WATCH | Why a two-state solution is so elusive: 

Why a two-state solution is nearly impossible to achieve

2 months ago

Duration 17:47

For decades, world leaders have sold an Israeli-Palestinian two-state solution as the best hope for peace in the region, but is it even possible? CBC’s Ellen Mauro breaks down the major challenges standing in the way.

In the months since, Palestinians continued suffering from severe shortages of food, fuel and medicine in a humanitarian crisis brought on by the Israeli offensive that has demolished much of the territory.

Britain's Foreign Secretary David Cameron, who was also in Riyadh for the WEF meeting, also described the Israeli proposal as "generous."

It included a 40-day pause in fighting and the release of potentially thousands of Palestinian prisoners as well as Israeli hostages, he told a WEF audience.

"I hope Hamas do take this deal and frankly, all the pressure in the world and all the eyes in the world should be on them today saying 'take that deal,'" Cameron said.

Cameron is among several foreign ministers in Riyadh, including from the U.S., France, Jordan and Egypt, as part of a diplomatic push to bring an end to the Gaza war.