She and Juan Problematico...I mean Pablo, hit it off early on so Clare felt completely cool heading to his hotel room in the wee hours of one morning and asking him to swim in the ocean with her. He agreed, and the two had non-fantasy suite sex while doing it. The next day, Juan Pablo told Clare he didn't want to set a bad example for his daughter and regretted it, leaving her confused. On top of that, on a later date when Clare basically begs him to say he loves her, he (apparently) whispers "I loved fucking you," instead. It took way too long, but Clare finally told Juan Pablo off after he dumped her at the final rose ceremony.